Thursday, July 14, 2011

Celestine: Week 7, Saturday

In Saturday by Ian McEwan the main character Henry Perowne is a neurosurgeon who is very engulfed in his work and very prideful about his skills of performing brain surgery. Henry Perowne is a loving husband and father who enjoy spending time with his family though it can be difficult because of his job and the time commitment. He has two adult children a daughter, Daisy, who he has not seen in six months and a son, Theo, who lives with him and his wife, Rosalind. Henry is looking forward to spending Saturday with his family because Henry will unite them all along with his father in law John Grammaticus for supper cooked by him. Before this dinner can occur Henry is disturbed by two incidents that indicates he is neither as safe nor as secure as he like to be after 9/11. The first event that shows Henry’s lack of security is his stance on taking Saddam Hussein out of power in Iraq. Henry originally believes that the war is unnecessary because he does not think anything will be solved from it and he is a confrontational man. His opinion is swayed when as Zoe Heller writes in “ Saturday”: One Day in the Life, “ He cannot help seeing things from the viewpoints of others: his children, his mother and his Iraqi patient, whose stories of torture in one of Saddam’s prisons have persuaded him that the invasion of Iraq is a probably a good idea (3, 2005).” Henry begins to think that the war is necessary because Saddam mistreats his citizens and uses his power for evil. In an argument when Daisy first arrives home they argue about his stance because Daisy does not like that her father thinks the war is needed and that people will not be able to tell its success for another five years. This infuriates Daisy because she feels like her father is avoiding his real opinion based on the facts presented. The argument between Daisy and her father represent a lack of security for Henry because he does not have a solid opinion and it can be changed depending on whom he is speaking too.

Also in Saturday and incident that shows Henry’s lack of safety is when Baxter and Nigel enter his home with Rosalind. Henry had not seen Baxter and his sidekick since he fled the accident earlier that day. For them to enter his home-unannounced shows that the world is not as safe as people would like to think. Like Nan A. Talese says in A Day in the Life, “Ian McEwan, through Perowne, examines the randomness that makes up a life, and the random events that can undo one (2,2005).” She allows the reader to understand that events can occur without the prior knowledge or preparation of the victim. This relates to 9/11 because the American citizens who were harmed and killed when the twin towers collapsed were not aware that this event was in occurrence because of they were they would not have been at work and national security would have been tighter. Had Henry predicted Baxter figuring out where he and his family lived they could have been protected and on guard for his arrival; their Saturday family reunion would have turned out the way he had hoped it would.

2 comments:

Mary McCay said...

Your point about Daisy is important. Her disagreement upsets her father. However, he is more disturbed when Baxter makes Daisy undress, and her father realizes she is pregnant. Why is that so disturbing to Henry?

Sonya said...

Sonya Bonnin - Celestine

You make an interesting point about Henry’s motives for being in favor of the war in Iraq. He felt insecure in the world post 9-11 and no amount of reasoning by way of his daughter would be able to dissuade him from the stance he had assumed. This is a commentary on the US and the world’s attitude after the terrorist attack of 9-11. They were looking for someone to blame, a target that could ease the tension and unrest everyone was feeling. There were no ties between Saddam and the bombing of the World Trade Center, and, as Daisy tells her father, not sufficient evidence pointing to the fact that Iraq possessed WMD. Still, war would be waged on Iraq. You later write about the incident in which Nigel and Baxter show up at Henry’s house looking to harm him and his family. I think this part is also very interesting especially since in this same dialog between Daisy and her father she tells him: “And doesn’t it ever occur to you that in attacking Iraq we’re doing the very thing the New York bombers wanted us to do-lash out , make more enemies in Arab countries and radicalize Islam.” Henry had incited a fight by humiliating Baxter in front of his men and now they had shown up at his own home armed and ready for confrontation. This is exactly what Daisy was afraid would happen if war were to be waged. Their world and consequently their lives would never be safe again.